Personal Trainers versus Strength Coaches
Personal trainers and strength coaches have a number of similarities; both work in the fitness field, work with a diverse clientele, and work non-typical work hours and days. Beyond that, there are a number of distinct differences between the practices of personal trainers and strength coaches. I currently work as a personal trainer and strength coach, and comments/opinions posted below are based upon my own experiences and interactions with other coaches and clientele.
Clientele
Personal trainers are often required to use an active approach in gaining new clientele and signing up new members. Unfortunately, many personal trainers act as glorified salesperson, where they convince you that their service of worthy of a specific fee. Personal trainers sell training packages to clientele. Such training packages may consist of as few as five sessions or up to 20-30 sessions, dependent upon the goals and finances of the targeted clientele. In contrast, strength coaches do not have to work for their clientele. Rather, they are assigned to athletes based upon their teams. These teams may have few athletes if the sport is considered an individual sport (i.e. golf) but may have much larger numbers if the sport is considered a team sport (i.e. football, soccer, baseball).
Interaction
Personal trainers may prescribe at home workouts to clientele or workouts that are to completed without supervision. In doing so, personal trainers may only meet with their clientele 1-2 times per week, but again this will vary primarily depending upon the clients’ finances. Strength coaches often meet with athletes anywhere from two to six days per week. All exercises, sets, and training days are performed under the guidance and supervision of the strength coach. With the exception of the summer period, all athletes will work out under the direct supervision of strength coaches.
Programming
The goals of clientele of personal trainers will vary somewhat. However, the most common goal of this clientele is to lose weight, increase fitness and look better. In contrast, the goal of athletes within strength and conditioning programs is to improve sports performance and reduce the incidence of injuries. Therefore, the training programs between personal trainers and strength coaches will be distinctly different. Athletes are welcome to lose weight, increase fitness and look better, but, if it is not under the recommendation of their team coach or strength coach- they will do so at their own time.
Strength coaches have the opportunity to program long term training plans. These training plans often utilize the long term athletic development model whereby coaches will periodize training program throughout a yearly cycle. Strength coaches will frequently change exercise selection and training goals throughout the year. For instance, teams that are in-season will usually work out less often and at a lower intensity compared to teams that are out of season or approaching their current season.
Program development by personal trainers for clientele does not vary too much throughout the designated training period. Exercises may change to a certain extent, but many exercises will remain a stable throughout the training program. With most personal training programs, there is a strong emphasis upon cardiovascular training. Running, walking, cycling and overall cardiovascular exercise prescription will account for 30-60% of a personal training program.
Attention to Detail
Training one to one in a personal training setting is a superior training method for clientele. However, this positive attribute must be weighed against the superior programming that strength coaches often put forward. Personal trainers have the opportunity to work with a single person whereas strength coaches work with multiple athletes at once. Therefore, personal trainers can often offer small training cues for clients and correct small, less subtle movement mistakes. Unless other strength coaches or interns are working with teams simultaneously, strength coaches can only pick up on larger, more obvious training mistakes. Strength coaches typically use the off-season to develop lifting proficiency among athletes while personal trainers can work on daily on attention to detail.
Working Hours
Morning hours for personal trainers and strength coaches are typically similar. Both begin their working days anywhere from 5-7am each morning during the working week. What differs with strength coaches is that they will typically not train teams between 10am-2pm as athletes attend class. The majority of training windows are early morning, mid-afternoon and late evening. For example, the football team train in the morning, soccer in the afternoon and baseball train in the evening. Personal trainers generally work throughout the day as most gyms will have a continual flow of clientele and members throughout the day.
Salary
Strength coaches typically have a fixed income, with 9-10 month contacts being most the most common working contracts. Most personal trainers do not have contracts as they work as self-employed within their respective gyms. Therefore, the salary of personal trainers can vary tremendously based upon location, hours worked and clientele. If job security is the goal, personal training might be a better option. If financial security, or fixed income is the goal, then working as a strength coach may be the best suited of the two professions. The salary of a strength coach will vary depending upon their experience and college. Division I coaches will typically be paid more than Division II, and NAIA strength coaches may only work on a part-time basis due to budget allowances at smaller schools.
Level of Legitimacy
Without a doubt, strength coaches are more respected and recognized as professionals when compared to personal trainers. There are numerous reasons for this. The problem with personal training is that any person can claim to be a personal trainer upon completing an online exam from various agencies. Therefore, a person with little to no knowledge of nutrition, training and fitness can become a trainer within a 24-48 hour training period. Strength coaches are held accountable for their knowledge through stringent standards enforced by nationally recognized organizations such as the NSCA. The prerequisites for entry into strength and conditioning coaching jobs are higher, as is the level of competition among candidates vying for open positions.
Summary
The purpose of this post was to highlight the varying functions of personal trainers and strength coaches. While the title of the post is personal trainers versus strength coaches- I do not believe that one profession is above or greater than the other. In some respects, it is like comparing these professions is like apples to oranges, but I do hope that this post has been successful in informing the health and fitness community about the role of strength coaches and personal trainers within the health and fitness field.